1
Alyssa's Kitchen (Custom cakes made to order & can be delivered)
from 333 Google reviews.
Fairly rated · Updated October 2026
The bakeries of New South Wales
As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated bakeries in New South Wales on Fair Measure are Alyssa's Kitchen (Custom cakes made to order & can be delivered) (5.0 from 333 Google reviews), Dessert Wagon AU (5.0 from 234 Google reviews) and House of Highness (5.0 from 179 Google reviews).
- Bakeries compared
- 752
- Google reviews
- 125,536
- Median rating
- 4.5
The bakeries of New South Wales: the top 50
2
Dessert Wagon AU
from 234 Google reviews.
3
House of Highness
from 179 Google reviews.
60 Manning St, Tuncurry NSW 2428
4
En Casa Cooking Space
from 142 Google reviews.
5
Mina Bakery Parramatta
from 119 Google reviews.
71 George St, Sydney NSW 2150
6
The Cheesecake Shop Ballina
from 119 Google reviews.
Ballina Central, 44 Bangalow Rd, Ballina NSW 2478
7
Color Drama Cakes
from 105 Google reviews.
8
Eaton Cakes
from 100 Google reviews.
9
MadebyD
from 100 Google reviews.
10
Prepress Coffee
from 100 Google reviews.
11
Lola Jô Cakes
from 93 Google reviews.
12
Constant Craving Cakes
from 91 Google reviews.
2 Enterprise Clos, Central Coast NSW 2250
13
Sugar Reef Dessert Bar
from 81 Google reviews.
19 Gerrale St, Sydney NSW 2230
14
SIMPLY SOURDOUGH BREAD
from 79 Google reviews.
97 Keen St, Lismore NSW 2480
15
Roya Sweets ( Persian sweets )
from 75 Google reviews.
Castle mall, 2/16 Terminus St
16
PUNU DELIGHT | Custom/Themed Cake MacArthur Campbelltown Camden Liverpool NSW
from 71 Google reviews.
17
Sugarbird Cakery
from 71 Google reviews.
5 Badgery St, Googong NSW 2620
18
The Cake House
from 65 Google reviews.
19
Eli Cake
from 63 Google reviews.
20
Liebe European Pastries
from 63 Google reviews.
21
QC Bakery & Cafe
from 55 Google reviews.
22
Just Add Flower
from 49 Google reviews.
23
Sumin Bakery
from 48 Google reviews.
24
The Bakery Witch
from 40 Google reviews.
25
Looma's Cakes
from 1,487 Google reviews.
26
Cakes by Acacia Simone
from 37 Google reviews.
27
Blak Cede Gunyah
from 561 Google reviews.
39A Kinghorne St, Nowra NSW 2541
28
Cake Art Studio Marayong 2148 NSW
from 407 Google reviews.
38 Railway Rd, Sydney NSW 2148
29
Cake Business Sydney - JK Cake Designs
from 306 Google reviews.
7 Hoyle Ave, Sydney NSW 2154
30
Hummingbird Bistro Byron Bay
from 269 Google reviews.
9 Bay Ln, Byron Bay NSW 2481
31
Studio Bakes
from 266 Google reviews.
261 Queen St, Sydney NSW 2560
32
Miquette
from 243 Google reviews.
214 Harbour Dr, Coffs Harbour NSW 2450
33
Rashel Bakery - Breakfast, Bakery, Cafe
from 33 Google reviews.
9/212 South Terrace
34
Sweet Custom Cakes
from 33 Google reviews.
35
Black Kat Espresso
from 235 Google reviews.
36
Lusinata
from 231 Google reviews.
127 Forest Rd, Sydney NSW 2220
37
yody
from 201 Google reviews.
47 Baylis St, Wagga Wagga NSW 2650
38
The Baker Bee
from 32 Google reviews.
39
Cassera's Patisserie, Pastry, Bakehouse
from 189 Google reviews.
10 Bellbowrie St, Port Macquarie NSW 2444
40
Caitlyn Cake Design
from 31 Google reviews.
41
Wyong Cake Palace
from 170 Google reviews.
42
Farrar & Sons Bakehouse
from 163 Google reviews.
224-228 Maitland Rd, Newcastle NSW 2304
43
Cocoa Cartel
from 161 Google reviews.
52 Pacific Dr, Port Macquarie NSW 2444
44
Van Gool Patisserie
from 30 Google reviews.
45
Wagga Vegan Bakery
from 30 Google reviews.
46
Hansel and Gretel Bakery Co.
from 140 Google reviews.
47
Star Patisserie
from 125 Google reviews.
48
Sugar Whipped Cakes
from 118 Google reviews.
633-639 Hume Hwy, Sydney NSW 2170
49
No Prato
from 28 Google reviews.
50
The Daily Cupcake Co.
from 28 Google reviews.
Fair Measure compared 752 bakeries in New South Wales, with 125,536 Google reviews between them. Of these, 752 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.5 from a median of 75 reviews.
Of the bakeries compared, the most reviewed is Robertson Pie Shop, with 2,625 Google reviews at 4.2.
How this list is ranked
Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews.
It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
Questions
- Which bakeries in New South Wales are the most fairly rated?
- As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated bakeries in New South Wales on Fair Measure are Alyssa's Kitchen (Custom cakes made to order & can be delivered) (5.0 from 333 Google reviews), Dessert Wagon AU (5.0 from 234 Google reviews) and House of Highness (5.0 from 179 Google reviews).
- How does Fair Measure rank bakeries in New South Wales?
- Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews. It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
- How many bakeries in New South Wales did Fair Measure compare?
- Fair Measure compared 752 bakeries in New South Wales, with 125,536 Google reviews between them. Of these, 752 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.5 from a median of 75 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.
Bakeries by place
New South Wales
- Albury
- Armidale
- Ballina
- Bankstown
- Bathurst
- Blacktown
- Bowral
- Byron Bay
- Campbelltown
- Castle Hill
- Central Coast
- Chatswood
- Coffs Harbour
- Cronulla
- Dubbo
- Forster
- Gosford
- Goulburn
- Hornsby
- Hurstville
- Inverell
- Katoomba
- Kiama
- Lismore
- Liverpool
- Maitland
- Manly
- Newcastle
- Nowra
- Orange
- Parramatta
- Penrith
- Port Macquarie
- Queanbeyan
- Sydney
- Tamworth
- Taree
- Tweed Heads
- Wagga Wagga
- Wollongong