1
The Craft Butcher
from 196 Google reviews.
108 Elder St, Newcastle NSW 2299
Fairly rated · Updated October 2026
The butchers of Newcastle
As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated butchers in Newcastle, NSW on Fair Measure are The Craft Butcher (4.9 from 196 Google reviews), Warners Bay Butchery (4.9 from 42 Google reviews) and Cardiff South Butchery and Pies (4.9 from 37 Google reviews).
- Butchers compared
- 20
- Google reviews
- 850
- Median rating
- 4.8
The butchers of Newcastle: the top 20
2
Warners Bay Butchery
from 42 Google reviews.
390 The Esplanade, Warners Bay NSW 2282
3
Cardiff South Butchery and Pies
from 37 Google reviews.
Helen St, Newcastle NSW 2285
4
Ozzie Meats
from 26 Google reviews.
328 Sandgate Rd, Newcastle NSW 2307
5
Valentine Butchers
from 17 Google reviews.
22 Allambee Pl, Valentine NSW 2280
6
Caves Beach Butchery
from 27 Google reviews.
64 Caves Beach Rd, Caves Beach NSW 2281
7
Heritage Meat Co
from 17 Google reviews.
6 Glebe St, Newcastle NSW 2290
8
Cardiff Quality Meats
from 16 Google reviews.
300 Main Rd, Newcastle NSW 2285
9
The Butchery on Brunker
from 66 Google reviews.
262 Brunker Rd, Newcastle NSW 2289
10
Darby Street Quality Meats
from 41 Google reviews.
11
Blackbutt Butchery
from 35 Google reviews.
62 Orchardtown Rd, Newcastle NSW 2305
12
Al-Madina Butcher & Grocery
from 3 Google reviews.
13
Mayfield Butcher and Grocers
from 90 Google reviews.
14
Sellers Meat Co.
from 50 Google reviews.
18 Mitchell St, Newcastle NSW 2291
15
Sanderson Meats on Beaumont Pty Ltd
from 10 Google reviews.
85 Beaumont St, Newcastle NSW 2303
16
Sellers Meat Co Whitebridge
from 1 Google review.
159 Dudley Rd, Whitebridge NSW 2290
17
Adam's Family Meats
from 45 Google reviews.
87 Regent St, New Lambton NSW 2305
18
Craig Cook - The Natural Butcher
from 41 Google reviews.
Shop 111/172 Mona Vale Rd, Sydney NSW 2075
19
Craig Cook - The Natural Butcher (Newcastle)
from 50 Google reviews.
Shop G12, Marketown Shopping Centre 23 Steel Street
20
Craig Cook The Natural Butcher (Charlestown)
from 40 Google reviews.
Shop 802, Pearson St, Charlestown Square Shopping Centre
Fair Measure compared 20 butchers in Newcastle, NSW, with 850 Google reviews between them. Of these, 20 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.8 from a median of 39 reviews.
Of the butchers compared, the most reviewed is The Craft Butcher, with 196 Google reviews at 4.9.
How this list is ranked
Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews.
It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
Questions
- Which butchers in Newcastle, NSW are the most fairly rated?
- As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated butchers in Newcastle, NSW on Fair Measure are The Craft Butcher (4.9 from 196 Google reviews), Warners Bay Butchery (4.9 from 42 Google reviews) and Cardiff South Butchery and Pies (4.9 from 37 Google reviews).
- How does Fair Measure rank butchers in Newcastle, NSW?
- Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews. It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
- How many butchers in Newcastle, NSW did Fair Measure compare?
- Fair Measure compared 20 butchers in Newcastle, NSW, with 850 Google reviews between them. Of these, 20 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.8 from a median of 39 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.