1
Gornelly’s
from 63 Google reviews.
Fairly rated · Updated October 2026
The restaurants of Castlemaine
As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated restaurants in Castlemaine, VIC on Fair Measure are Gornelly’s (4.9 from 63 Google reviews), SPROUT Bakery (4.9 from 44 Google reviews) and NIRA Coffee (5.0 from 15 Google reviews).
- Restaurants compared
- 24
- Google reviews
- 4,898
- Median rating
- 4.5
The restaurants of Castlemaine: the top 24
2
SPROUT Bakery
from 44 Google reviews.
3
NIRA Coffee
from 15 Google reviews.
4
Super Hero Banh Mi Vietnamese Takeaway
from 170 Google reviews.
5
Melody Castlemaine
from 17 Google reviews.
6
Bella Fresca Pizzeria
from 159 Google reviews.
219 Barker St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
7
Naam Pla Thai Take-away
from 151 Google reviews.
36 Hargraves St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
8
Klua Sathorn
from 163 Google reviews.
9
Nếp Castlemaine - Vietnamese Soul
from 130 Google reviews.
188 Barker St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
10
Coffee Basics Das Kaffeehaus
from 1,599 Google reviews.
9 Walker St
11
Love Shack Brewing Co
from 259 Google reviews.
12
Taste of The Orient Yum Cha House
from 148 Google reviews.
223 Barker St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
13
Lunchbox Sushi
from 64 Google reviews.
85 Mostyn St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
14
Sideshow Burgers Castlemaine
from 19 Google reviews.
15
McShanag's Bakery
from 57 Google reviews.
16
Lazy Bones Cafe
from 89 Google reviews.
17
Castlemaine Noodle Bar
from 116 Google reviews.
18
Tandoori Cuizine Indian Restaurant
from 156 Google reviews.
16 Lyttleton St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
19
Papas Fish Shop
from 197 Google reviews.
99 Mostyn St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
20
New China Restaurant
from 214 Google reviews.
319 Barker St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
21
The Royal Sultan Restaurant & Bar
from 283 Google reviews.
22
Big Jim's Pizza
from 198 Google reviews.
93 Mostyn St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
23
Boss Burger Co. Bendigo
from 215 Google reviews.
24
Blue Sea Fish Shop
from 372 Google reviews.
91 Mostyn St, Castlemaine VIC 3450
Fair Measure compared 24 restaurants in Castlemaine, VIC, with 4,898 Google reviews between them. Of these, 24 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.5 from a median of 154 reviews.
Of the restaurants compared, the most reviewed is Coffee Basics Das Kaffeehaus, with 1,599 Google reviews at 4.5.
How this list is ranked
Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews.
It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
Questions
- Which restaurants in Castlemaine, VIC are the most fairly rated?
- As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated restaurants in Castlemaine, VIC on Fair Measure are Gornelly’s (4.9 from 63 Google reviews), SPROUT Bakery (4.9 from 44 Google reviews) and NIRA Coffee (5.0 from 15 Google reviews).
- How does Fair Measure rank restaurants in Castlemaine, VIC?
- Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews. It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
- How many restaurants in Castlemaine, VIC did Fair Measure compare?
- Fair Measure compared 24 restaurants in Castlemaine, VIC, with 4,898 Google reviews between them. Of these, 24 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.5 from a median of 154 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.